Date: Oct 9, 2006, 3:33pm
hi Aleksey, I have noticed something with the Marquis compressor which prevents me from using the Dry Knob. When I am using very hard compression settings, as soon as I bring up the Dry knob, the output gets EXTREMELY loud. When sitting at around 50% it is the loudest and at 0% and 100% the output is EXTREMELY soft.
Try some seriously hard compression, threshold -40 db, ratio 50:1 and you'll see it immediately.
WARNING: Put a limiter after it or you'll blow your speakers ! :D
Any idea why this happens ? I find the behaviour very confusing. OH and by the way, this is the finest compresssor I have heard in native VST land, and I have heard ALL of them ! :D
Cheers
Fots
Date: Oct 9, 2006, 4:23pm
This behavior is to be expected. If you do not want it you can disable the 'Makeup' (make-up gain) function.
Date: Oct 9, 2006, 4:24pm
On the other hand, I may add some fixes to this make-up gain calculation in the future.
Date: Oct 9, 2006, 5:44pm
Sounds good Aleksey, I guess the biggest difficulty would be maintaining compatibility with previous versions when adding a new make-up gain mode but I agree that it could be improved to make the use of the Dry knob a lot more predictable.
Just an idea...
- Do make-up gain the same way as most other compressors (i.e. currently it's based on an average ? instead of peak level)
- Then the Dry portion of the sound does not go through makeup gain at all and you have a very simple wet / dry control between this compressed output and the original sound.
Just a few thoughts, keep up the awesome work !
Fots
Date: Oct 9, 2006, 6:31pm
Speaking of other compressors, they use exactly the peak level. I was trying to use average level. However, I also add Dry gain into equation - this is probably adding its complexities, because equation is non-linear.
In the worst case, it may be a problem within the equation itself (maybe I've simply overlooked something). But I won't be able to fix anything in this version due to backwards compatibility requirement. However, this can be done in the next version branch.
Date: Oct 10, 2006, 11:03am
Cool, sounds good :D Thanks for your time and help
Fots